top of page


2 November 2023

Victims of Melissa Caddick's Ponzi Scheme Seek Justice, Highlighting the Importance of Diligent SMSF Auditors

In a significant legal development, victims of Melissa Caddick's elaborate Ponzi scheme have initiated a class action against the auditors responsible for reviewing their self-managed superannuation funds (SMSFs). As reported in the SMH, Melbourne law firm Mackay Chapman has filed a lawsuit on behalf of 24 investors who suffered losses due to Caddick's fraudulent activities, alleging negligence, misleading conduct, and breaches of the Corporations Act by the auditors.

The case raises essential questions about the role of SMSF auditors in safeguarding investors' financial interests. SMSF audits are a crucial step in ensuring the validity and accuracy of financial statements, as well as compliance with superannuation legislation. This article sheds light on the significance of diligent SMSF auditors in preventing financial fraud and protecting investors.

Melissa Caddick's Disappearance and Ponzi Scheme

Melissa Caddick, a fraudulent financial advisor, disappeared in November 2020, following a raid on her home by Federal Police acting on behalf of ASIC. The raid was related to a $23 million Ponzi scheme that had been operating since 2012. Caddick had deceived her friends and family into believing she was investing their money in shares or superannuation funds. Each month, she created fraudulent documents to mislead investors about the performance of their shares, while secretly embezzling millions for her extravagant lifestyle.

SMSF Auditors' Role in the Scandal

One of the key elements in this case is the alleged failure of SMSF auditors to detect fraudulent activities. The auditors in question provided audit reports that gave the SMSFs a clean bill of health, despite the existence of fraudulent documents and missing shares. This highlights the critical role SMSF auditors play in ensuring the financial integrity of superannuation funds.

Auditors' Close Relationships and Self-Interest Threats

The case also underscores the potential risks associated with close relationships between auditors and those who refer clients to them. Such relationships can create self-interest, familiarity, or intimidation threats. In Caddick's case, she regularly used an auditor with whom she had a close relationship, raising questions about independence and impartiality.

Auditor's Disqualification and Legal Action

One of the auditors named in the class action, Khanh Huynh, was permanently banned by ASIC from being an SMSF auditor due to his "close relationship" with a client who referred many SMSF clients. This disqualification reflects the regulatory consequences auditors can face when their independence and integrity are compromised.

The Importance of Diligent SMSF Auditors

The ongoing class action against the auditors involved in Melissa Caddick's Ponzi scheme highlights the vital role SMSF auditors play in protecting investors from financial fraud. These auditors are responsible for ensuring that SMSFs adhere to financial regulations and that investors' interests are safeguarded. Their impartiality and diligence are essential to maintaining the integrity of self-managed superannuation funds.

The class action will continue in December, serving as a reminder of the importance of robust SMSF audit practices and the need for auditors to act with honesty and integrity to protect the financial well-being of SMSF investors.


Read the SMH report here

bottom of page